President Trump’s immigration policy, students speak up [Opinion]

March 22, 2017

Donald Trump, throughout his campaign and into his presidency, has stirred up much controversy since 2015. At the very center of this controversy sits his immigration policy. The major components of  President Trump’s immigration policy include construction of a US-Mexico border wall, increased deportations of undocumented immigrants, and elimination of “sanctuary cities.” The President’s strong stance regarding these hot-button issues aroused either ardent support or severe criticism from organizations and voters.

Defending the border and preserving our heritage

Donald Trump supports erecting a wall on the southern border separating Mexico and the United States. The wall guarantees US sovereignty as well as protection for Americans. The President’s proposal also aims to protect the jobs and wages of American citizens.

In addition, the influx of illegal immigration poses threats to those individuals, especially women. A shocking statistic was revealed that about 80% of Central American females who travel to America through Mexico are raped or sexually assaulted, according to the directors of migrant shelters who were interviewed by Fusion, an online newspaper. Another related and significant issue is that America currently struggles with a drug epidemic that continues to devastatingly affect its population. According to The Recovery Village, a rehabilitation center dedicated to helping recovering drug users, “Most of the illicit drugs come into the United States across the US and Mexico border.” The wall places a needed physical barrier between Mexico and the United States so that border agents can stop the flow of drugs and illegal immigrants to the United States.

Deportation

President Donald Trump has promised to deport “bad hombres” and “bad dudes” since he announced his candidacy. Deportations to a person’s country of origin are carried out by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), an agency of the federal government. Currently, there are roughly 11.1 million illegal immigrants in the US, according to the Pew Research Center.  The LA Times notes that up to 8 million people may eventually be deported under President Trump. This may well prove to be impractical because of the vast resources that would have to be dedicated to deporting such a vast number of people; therefore, one may argue that only illegal immigrants with criminal records should be deported.  According to Politifact, so far under President Trump, 75 percent of the people deported had criminal records , while 82-92 percent of those deported under President Obama had them. Deportations will continue to be carried out under President Trump, and the efforts are likely to be increased and prove beneficial to the United States.

Sanctuary Cities

Sanctuary cities have policies in effect that limit the amount of cooperation between local authorities and the federal government regarding immigration policies, according to The New York Times. Those municipalities shield illegal immigrants from deportation. Mayors such as Rahm Emanuel of Chicago and Bill DeBlasio of New York have expressed their intent to maintain their cities’ status despite threats from President Trump to cut federal funding to cities that offer refuge to illegal immigrants. Such suspension of federal funding to sanctuary cities has been popular among GOP  congressional member,s including Republican Texas representatives Louie Gohmert and Brian Babin. Illegal immigrants break US law by entering this country, and to protect them from the consequences of their actions is wrong. A mayor’s priority should be with the American citizens of his or her city.

Despite the controversy surrounding President Trump’s immigration policies, he continues to move forward with his promises. While they may seem harsh, they  ultimately represent the best  policies for the country.

View 2 Comments

These policies threaten what makes America great

Many Americans thought that Donald Trump’s proposed US-Mexico border wall was never going to materialize, but they were wrong.

President Trump has clearly shown that he intends to begin construction in the near future. CNBC estimates the cost to range anywhere from 12-15 billion dollars. During the 2016 campaign, Trump insisted that Mexico would pay for the wall. Now Trump has asked Congress to provide the funds which Mexico will pay back to the United States. These demands put the prospects of future relations between the U.S. and Mexico on a negative track. High profile individuals such as Pope Francis have spoken out emphatically against the wall: “A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian. This is not the gospel.” Many people believe that, beside damaging U.S. relations with a close neighbor and ally, President Trump’s plan runs counter to cherished American values.

Deportation

Deportation of undocumented immigrants remains a high priority in President Trump’s administration. Time Magazine observes that “the administration would have to grapple with how to pay for jail space to detain everyone and what to do with children caught crossing the border with their parents.”  The fear of deportation is a horrible reality that affects an estimated 11 million immigrants in America, many of whom have lived and worked here for decades. Historically, America has proudly accepted its identity as a “melting pot” which welcomes people of all races, religions, and ethnic backgrounds. Now, President Trump’s stance on border security and immigration is discouraging this founding American ideal.

Sanctuary Cities

Sanctuary cities are a little known  or understood aspect of the immigration crisis. These self-designated cities strive to protect resident undocumented immigrants  from deportation by not voluntarily reporting them to the federal government. It is daring for a city to identify itself as a sanctuary city due to the fact that it puts them at risk for retaliatory federal budget cuts. According to The Rolling Stone Magazine, Mayor Ed Lee of San Francisco asserted last year, “No matter the threats made by President-elect Trump, San Francisco will remain a Sanctuary City.” Despite the risk, these cities have continued to stay true to their values. The New York Times identified over 200 sanctuary cities in the country.  They have maintained their moral commitment to protect their residents from deportation. These cities stand up for what they believe is just, not just what federal law tells them to do.

View 1 Comment

The Pioneer • Copyright 2024 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in