The detention files
New policy receives mixed reviews from students
November 24, 2019
Remember last year when everyone was saying how detention wasn’t that bad and you could do whatever you wanted there? Well, that’s changed.
The dean’s office made the decision to change the detention policy for the 2019-20 school year. Instead of leaving the activity to the discretion of the proctor, students must spend an hour copying the school discipline section of the student handbook.
This new policy has caught the attention of students, and some, like sophomore Dom Fallon, are up in arms about it. Dom said, “Writing the handbook is dumb, and I get nothing out of it.” Christian Ghoubrial, a senior, agrees with Dom. Christian served a detention recently, and said, “I was miserable. It was a horrendous experience, and it makes me never want to serve a detention again.”
The change was significant for a reason. Ms. Julie Hudec, Dean of Students, said, “There were too many kids in detention, and we wanted to make it more of a punishment.” Ms. Hudec also added that she thinks the change has been effective because fewer kids are getting detentions due to the stricter consequence. She finished by saying, “Who wants to sit there and write for an hour anyway?”
Fewer students may be getting detentions, but some are still upset. One of these is senior Sarah Eckman, who said, “It’s not a positive reinforcement of the rules.” She believes that the current punishment is not teaching a lesson or helping kids improve behavior in any way.
Previously, students in detention were supposed to do their homework or sit silently. Emily Alessia, another senior, thinks that students should be able to do their homework during detention. She said, “Copying the handbook doesn’t make sense, and it should go back to the way that it used to be, and kids should be able to do their homework.”
Junior Matt Fazio agrees with Emily, saying, “If kids do their homework during detention, it could help them to focus on their schoolwork instead of whatever it is that got them in detention.” Matt thinks that if students who violate the rules are underachieving academically, then working on homework would benefit them much more than just sitting there and copying the handbook.
While some students think another change in the policy is the answer, others believe the current punishment is having an impact. Senior Colton Levey thinks that the new detention policy is good for changing the way kids think of detention. He said, “I think it will make kids regret getting detention, because the punishment is stricter.”
With that being said, Colton still feels that no matter the changes that are made, kids are still going to continue to get detentions at the same rate.
Barty • Jan 22, 2020 at 10:02 am
Detention is honestly a joke. Why do the deans want to read 10+ of the same thing they enforce the handbook yet we are writing it for them to read? harshening a punishment and think that will make less people get punished is foolish Ghandi once said you can’t drive out darkness with darkness only light can do that, I think we should listen to ghandi, and wouldn’t Christ want us to sit and reflect over why we are in detention and try to correct it and realize why it was wrong, writing a handbook in all honesty just makes kids more mad and want to act up realistically. Also strongly agree that they should make sure students aren’t targeted and eliminate the favorites and how rules get passed by special favorites and only apply to some individuals.
Dan Crissman • Nov 26, 2019 at 1:15 pm
I don’t like detention.
Aaron Hric • Nov 26, 2019 at 1:03 pm
I got a detention from Mrs. Byrne for not doing and turning in my homework then, a few weeks later, I got another for the same reason so it obviously had no effect on my view of doing my homework and both times I went into detention I thought “Well, I guess this is happening,” however, if I could do and finish my homework in detention I may have not gotten that second detention for not having my homework done.
Abby Krzywicki • Nov 26, 2019 at 1:01 pm
Yes the punishment is harsher, and it is a miserable one in deed. However, on the side of the school the punishment is in fact doing its intention, bringing down the detention rate. However, what i really thinks needs to be dealt with is what causes people to get detentions. The tardy rule. I received a detention for having three tardies from August 2019-November 2019. Isn’t that a little radical? Three tardies for almost two complete quarters? Didn’t our tardies reset very quarter last year? I personally have a forty minute drive to school everyday and traffic on Wyoga Lake Road is miserable, everyone can agree on that. Also, I know people have even longer drives than me. And people can argue by saying, “just leave earlier!” However, I already wake up at 6:20 am to leave for school and 7:00 am. I arrive anywhere between 7:45-8:05. Traffic is random and unpredictable, so punishing people for being late due to something they cannot predict is unjust and unreasonable. The rule should be adapted to accommodate for people driving longer distances and have to travel through more traffic.
Lauren DePasquale • Nov 26, 2019 at 12:37 pm
Rewriting the discipline section of the handbook does absolutely nothing for students getting detentions. Detention is supposed to be a learning experience and copying down the handbook doesn’t teach us. Acting responsibly and following the “rules” doesn’t necessarily have anything to do with getting a detention and rules aren’t rules unless they apply to everyone. Some students get detentions for things that other students don’t which isn’t fair. Instead of making us rewrite the discipline section, why not take more interest in what students are getting in trouble for, help them rather than boring them to death for an hour and making their hands cramp.
Give us an opportunity to understand how our actions are wrong instead of a punishment that no one takes seriously or learns from.
Keezy Allen • Nov 26, 2019 at 11:16 am
Well @Mr. Dowdell you’re sassy, if teachers could get detentions you would be singing a different tune.
Reena • Nov 26, 2019 at 11:05 am
It is funny how the last article about detention actually made an impact in the school society. Many students are complaining about the new rule of detention. Yet, that is the effect of the media at school. Remember, the deans also read the pioneer!
Mr. Dowdell • Nov 26, 2019 at 7:53 am
Well students, you don’t like detentions anymore. Great, just follow the rules and everything will be fine. Stop your whining, and act responsibly.